The La Grange Inn in West Islip, Long Island, is one of the area's oldest surviving historic buildings and is believed to date to around 1750. It stands at the corner of Montauk Highway and Higbie Lane and is often cited as one of the oldest inns that continuously served travelers on Long Island. [preservati...island.org], [westislipa...iation.org]
Early History (1700s-1800s)
The inn was established by members of the Higbie family, one of the earliest families to settle in the area. [longisland...roject.org], [fireislandnews.com]
During the colonial period and early years of the United States, it served travelers moving along what became Montauk Highway. [longisland...roject.org], [westislipa...iation.org]
Historical references suggest the establishment was licensed as an inn by about 1750, although an exact construction date has never been definitively documented. [westisliph...ociety.org], [westisliph...ociety.org]
In the early 19th century, proprietor Samuel Higbie renamed it "La Grange," likely in honor of the French estate and hometown associated with the Marquis de Lafayette. [fireislandnews.com]
Later Years
Over the centuries, the property operated alternately as an inn, hotel, hostelry, restaurant, and gathering place, with multiple additions and expansions added to the original structure. [preservati...island.org], [westislipa...iation.org]
The inn remained a well-known West Islip landmark throughout the 20th century. It changed ownership several times, and Uwe Paulssen owned and operated it from 1968 until 2001. [westisliph...ociety.org], [fireislandnews.com]
Preservation Effort
After becoming vacant in the early 2010s, the building faced possible demolition as part of commercial redevelopment plans. This sparked a major community preservation campaign. [preservati...island.org], [westislipa...iation.org]
Following years of negotiations, the historic core of the building was preserved, relocated slightly on the property, and restored to resemble its mid-19th-century appearance. [preservati...island.org], [westislipa...iation.org]
The restored structure became the home of the West Islip History Center, operated by the West Islip Historical Society, opening to the public in 2019. [westisliph...ociety.org], [fireislandnews.com]
Interesting Fact
A local legend long claimed that George Washington stayed at the inn during his 1790 tour of Long Island. Modern research indicates that he actually stayed nearby at Sagtikos Manor, although the story remains part of local folklore. [fireislandnews.com]
Today, La Grange Inn is regarded as one of West Islip's most important historic landmarks and a symbol of the community's colonial heritage. [preservati...island.org], [westisliph...ociety.org]